Testing
children's intelligence is the only tools that it used almost in many countries
to measure children’s intelligence. In this test, children are not measure
accurately due to the fact that this assessment does not include all the
domains of development, it is only include specific areas and exclude many
aspect that might show more about child’s intelligence. Besides, it is not fair
to determine child’ intelligence based only on this test because many children
are doing great in the class and having highest scores but just hearing test or
assessment that would be enough to panic them and put them under pressure. And
what also important, is that Testing usually has a limit time, and most
children cannot finish the assessment in time, that of course does not indicate
that this child is not intelligence or his ability to learn is limited. Hence, I
hope that in testing or assessment should take into consideration that every
child is unique and his ability to internalize, and recall material is different
from another.
In my country,
which is Iraq, we assess children based on two types of test. The first one is
done in the middle of the school year, and the second one at the end of the school.
In both test, children are measure in different areas such as math, science, language
and other aspects. During the test, children are given two weeks or more depending on their grade,
and every child is responsible for memorizing
everything he learned from the cover to cover. This form a challenge for every
child since it is very hard to recall the whole material. I remember when I was
in middle school; my mom was used to come with me because she knows that I will
throw and get sick. Just remember these days make my feel sick. Truly, I believe
this test does not give accurate information about children intelligence. This
topic make me remember my friend when we were in the last year of high school,
she used to be the top in the class from the elementary till almost the last year.
During the test, she was very scared and under pressure, the result, she did
not take a good score that might qualify her to be a doctor, which was her
dream at that time. Everyone in Iraq,
consider the last year of the high school is the most important period in
student’s life since it will determine his/her future later. Therefore, we believe
that the person who is lucky in his life will pass the test and get the highest
mark, and the one who is not lucky even if he was very intelligent, will not
perform good at this test. Actually, we consider assessment is just like luck.
In conclusion,
I wish that when we measure children’s intelligence, we do not need to focus on
this test only; we need to take into consideration other aspect of child’s
development such as emotional or social skills. I hope that every teacher
should educate children that when are not doing well in the test, that does not
mean they are not intelligence. Many children get frustrated when they know
that their scores are very low and that may affect their performance later. I would
love to make every child feel with comfort when hearing assessment or testing.
http://faculty.ccp.edu/dept/viewpoints/f03v4n1/suskie.html
Bushra, Thank you for sharing your very personal story. It is difficult to imagine a system even more so restrictive that tests are the only measure of competence. I agree with your position that testing does not account for multiple intelligences. It lets the system know if the student is good at taking test. Education psychologists suggest that in addition to academic intelligence, there are creative, practical and emotional intelligence. Berger, 2009, p. 325). However, the last three would require skilled observers and would be expensive. Assessment on a large scale appears to force competitive comparison of student achievement.
ReplyDeleteReference
Berger, K.S. (2009). The developing person through childhood. (5th ed.). New York, NY: Worth Publishers